Performance vs. Brand Awareness? Brand Builds the Hype. Performance Seals the Deal.
Brand builds the hype. Performance seals the deal. The smartest marketers know you need both.
For years, marketers have felt forced to choose between building long-term brand equity and chasing short-term ROI. But new insights from TikTok + Tracksuit, Ogilvy Social.Lab, and Pretty Little Marketer reveal a reality where both are not only possible but essentially codependent. In the age of social-first discovery and “messy middle” decision-making, the brands that win are the ones that seamlessly blend storytelling with selling.
So why are so many still treating them like a trade-off? And more importantly — how do we bring them together, and who’s already doing it best?
1. Brand Awareness Fuels Performance
For years, performance marketing promised immediacy: clear metrics, fast ROI, and the ability to track every click. But new research is exposing the limits of that approach — especially when it’s done in a brand vacuum.
Recent findings from the Awareness Advantage report, a collaboration between Tracksuit and TikTok, illustrate this shift vividly. The study analyzed 147 brands and found that conversion efficiency — not click-through rate — is the true growth unlock, and that it is deeply tied to brand awareness.
Key insights:
- Brands with high awareness (~60%) achieved 2.86× higher conversion rates than those with low awareness (~20%).
- Even a modest jump from 30% to 40% awareness led to 43% more efficient performance.
- CTR showed no correlation with brand awareness. But CVR (conversion rate) did.
The biggest jump in conversion efficiency happened when brands crossed the 37% awareness threshold — a critical tipping point where familiarity drives action.
Performance media often gets more expensive as a brand scales. Brand awareness helps offset rising costs by making every impression more efficient. Think of it as a multiplier: the stronger the brand, the better performance media performs.
The Real KPI? Conversion Efficiency.
Marketers are now encouraged to move beyond CTR and consider CVR and return on ad spend (ROAS) in the context of brand health. Emerging models — like ADBUG (Advertising Brand Uplift Gains) — help quantify how much of performance success is attributable to brand equity versus audience targeting or creative execution.
It’s a major mindset shift. And it’s backed by data.
“Brand is the foundation on which performance success is built. The stronger the brand, the stronger the foundation.”
— TikTok Marketing Science team
As TikTok’s Head of Marketing Science said, “If we want to maintain efficiency as we grow our performance marketing, we need to grow our brand awareness in tandem.”
2. Social Search Is the New SEO
Social platforms have undergone a quiet revolution. They’re no longer just places to connect with friends or scroll passively. Increasingly, TikTok, Pinterest, Instagram, and even Reddit are being used as search engines.
According to Pretty Little Marketer’s Rise of Social Search report:
- 40% of Gen Z use TikTok as their primary search tool
- Pinterest processes over 5 billion searches a month
- Instagram’s Explore page has evolved into a visual search layer
Consumers now use TikTok for product reviews, Pinterest for planning, and Instagram to validate brand credibility. Their path to purchase is non-linear, fluid, and full of cross-platform exploration. This behavior demands content that’s searchable, snackable, and story-driven.
Tactics for social search:
- Use platform-native phrases and trending terms in captions and voiceovers
- Write hooky, keyword-rich headlines in the first line of posts
- Build content around questions your audience is actively searching
When your brand shows up in those micro-moments of curiosity or need, you’re no longer just building awareness — you’re meeting intent.
3. Emotional Resonance Drives ROI
Gen Z doesn’t convert without connection. According to Tumblr’s community study, 85% of Gen Z expects brands to foster a sense of belonging. They reward brands that participate in culture, show vulnerability, and create shared experiences — not just push products.
Performance tactics alone won’t break through if the brand isn’t relatable, trusted, or memorable.
Examples:
- A TikTok creator’s low-fi story about struggling with acne — and how a brand helped — performs better than a polished ad.
- A carousel that says “What I wish I knew before switching to mineral sunscreen” earns saves and shares and drives sales.
- Brands that comment back, repost fan content, and co-create moments deepen community and brand equity.
When brand and performance work together, you get conversion that sticks.
4. Content Strategy Is Always-On and Built for Discovery
Forget 12-month content calendars. Today’s leading brands operate with a layered, agile content strategy:
- Evergreen: Educational and searchable content built for long-term discovery (e.g., “3 ways to wear one blazer”).
- Cultural Big Bets: Moment-driving campaigns or creator collabs (like CeraVe’s Michael Cera stunt).
- Responsive Content: Timely posts that tap into trends, memes, and cultural conversation.
Ogilvy recommends brands reserve 15–25% of their content budget for real-time, experimental content. This allows space to test what resonates organically — and scale winners with paid support.
And with the rise of social search, every piece of content should be built for discoverability:
- Keyword-forward captions
- Subtitles and text overlays
- Platform-specific formatting and tone
Today’s best-performing content isn’t always the most polished—it’s the most timely, useful, and culturally fluent.
5. Social Is the Growth Engine
Social isn’t just a channel — it’s the connective tissue powering the full marketing funnel.
It informs product development, amplifies campaigns, builds communities, and drives direct sales. The most innovative brands now launch first on social and then extend across paid, PR, and in-store.
Two perfect-case examples:
- Heinz’s “Seemingly Ranch” product drop (March 2023) came directly from a viral TikTok moment — and sold out.
- McDonald’s “WcDonald’s” anime campaign (February 2024) tapped fan culture to drive massive in-store and digital traffic.
Social isn’t just where the conversation starts — it’s where brand and performance converge.
Final Thoughts: Stop Choosing — Start Blending
The takeaway for modern marketers?
It’s time to retire the false binary of brand vs. performance. In a world where consumers discover products through TikTok reviews, validate trust on Instagram, and make purchases through social storefronts — brand and performance aren’t separate efforts; they’re sequential and often simultaneous steps in the same journey.
The most future-ready brands don’t just balance these disciplines — they blend them into unified strategies that evolve with consumer behavior. That means:
- Building content that’s emotionally resonant and action-oriented
- Investing in brand equity to fuel performance ROI
- Designing for discoverability at every stage — from search to story to swipe
- Measuring success with full-funnel metrics, not just last-click attribution
This shift doesn’t require abandoning performance goals or ignoring brand consistency. It demands a more sophisticated, audience-first approach that prioritizes relevance, agility, and human connection.
Because when performance marketing is backed by trust, and brand storytelling is backed by intent, you’re not just reaching people — you’re moving them.
Brand converts best when it’s discoverable. Performance scales fastest when it’s trusted.
The future of marketing isn’t a balancing act — it’s a fusion. And the brands that embrace that fusion will be the ones that grow faster, last longer, and mean more to the people they serve.
Want more deep dives like this? Make sure to subscribe to our weekly newsletter, LF Pool Party, for everything social media professionals need to know to make their strategy a 10/10.
